Organic vs Non-Organic Shampoo: What is the Difference?

Natural and organic products have come a long way over the past few decades. This is especially true when it comes to personal care products like shampoos. Because of the push for safer products for us to use, there is a boon in this market.

In fact, there are now options available to choose from, so with all those choices, how do you find one that will work for you and your hair needs? We thought we would help you out a bit and create this guide to do just that.

Below, we will look at a few of our choices for the best natural organic shampoos on the market. Along with this, we also crafted a buyer’s guide that you can use if none of the options we chose makes the cut. So without further ado, let’s take a look at some of the top options for natural organic shampoos and how to use them.

Best Natural Organic Shampoos Reviews

MAJESTIC PURE Apple Cider Vinegar Shampoo & Avocado Coconut Conditioner

Our first shampoo is one that is formulated to help with scalp itch and dandruff while restoring the luster of your hair. This formula is carefully crafted with natural ingredients, and that is why we think it is one of the best out there.

Product Highlights

Here are the main features you can expect with this product:

  • Sulfate & paraben free
  • Color-safe
  • Cruelty-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Compatible with all hair types
  • Formulated to clarify and hydrate hair and scalp

The Good

There is a lot to say about this shampoo, and that is why we chose it for this list. The formulation of this product creates a gentle and mild shampoo that packs a punch when it comes to dandruff. This is partly because of the moisturization capabilities of the ingredients used to make it.

On top of all that, this formula can be used regardless of your hair type, and that gives it more versatile usability, which makes it great for a large household that wants to switch to a natural organic shampoo.

The Bad

Just because there is a lot to rave about when it comes to this shampoo doesn’t mean that there are not some flaws. If you don’t have a large family or like to travel a lot, the size of the bottle may be a bit cumbersome. In regards to that bottle, the pump system seems to have quite a bit of a problem. Many people have experienced it getting sticky and not working properly.

In the end, the choice is yours, but neither of these two issues is universal, nor do they affect the performance of the shampoo itself.


  • Very budget-friendly in comparison to others
  • Gentle and mild yet very effective on dandruff
  • Can be used on all hair types, lengths, and styles
  • Crafted with ingredients that increase moisturization capability


  • Large bottles make it not very travel-friendly
  • Some have had a problem with the pump system getting stuck


PURA D’OR Gold Label Shampoo & Conditioner

For those who are dealing with thinning hair, this next shampoo is a great choice. It is clinically tested when it comes to hair loss, but it offers so much more than that. Anyone would be making a smart investment by purchasing it.

Product Highlights

Here are the main features you can expect with this product:

  • Sulfate-free
  • Compatible with all hair types
  • Stimulates hair follicles
  • Promotes circulation
  • 19 active herbal ingredients
  • 17 DHT blockers
  • Packed with vitamins & minerals
  • Vegan-friendly and cruelty-free

The Good

Some people suffer from thinning hair, and that can affect their confidence. If this is a problem you suffer from, and you want a natural organic shampoo, then this one from PURA D’OR is a potential option. Not only will it help stimulate your hair follicles, but it will also help create volume in the hair you have.

To keep that hair healthy, it is crafted with ingredients that promote hydration and protect hair. On top of all of that, unlike other products, this one works even with oily hair.

The Bad

Of course, there are a few things that we would be remiss without mentioning as you try to make your decision. If overused, some have ended up with a dry and itchy scalp. In other words, this may not be a great everyday shampoo choice. Also, any time premium-grade ingredients are used, you can expect an elevated price tag. This means that if you have a tight budget, you may want to look for another product.

Though there are a few issues overall, when we looked at this shampoo, it was clear that it was a high-quality option. For those who are dealing with hair loss or thinning hair, maybe this should be on your list of potential options.


  • Formulated to help improve the volume of your hair
  • Hydrates and protects hair from more damage
  • Designed to combat thinning hair
  • Helps strengthen hair from the root to the tip
  • Product works well even if you have oily hair


  • Some find their scalp excessively dry after use
  • May not be a good choice if you are on a budget


Botanic Hearth Biotin Shampoo & Conditioner

The next natural and organic shampoo we chose is a biotin formula crafted with ginger oil and keratin. This shampoo from Botanic Hearth is well-crafted, which is key when looking at a personal care item.

Product Highlights

Here are the main features you can expect with this product:

  • Sulfate & paraben free
  • Cruelty-free
  • Crafted with ginger oil and keratin
  • Compatible with all hair types

The Good

When you are dealing with frizzy or curly hair, you probably have a hard time finding a product that is good for your hair. When on the hunt for a natural organic shampoo, you should definitely consider this one from Botanic Hearth.

The shampoo is a lightweight formula that removes build-up and leaves no extra weight on your hair after use. There is even a chance that this formula can help with hair loss. Plus, it smells nice, too!

The Bad

That being said, some issues might cause some to reconsider choosing this shampoo. The largest issue is for those who have oily hair. Although this formula is good for almost every hair type, one type will not get as good of results. Those who have oily hair should look at another shampoo. Some have also experienced a residue left on the hair after using it.

In the end, as long as you don’t have oily hair, this shampoo is a fine choice. As for the other issue, it is not a global occurrence, so you might be able to overlook the few instances it has occurred.


  • Ingredients in the formula have a pleasant smell
  • Formula is effective for frizzy and curly hair
  • Designed to be light in order to not add any weight to the hair
  • May help reduce hair loss after just a few uses


  • Some have experienced a residue left on their hair after use
  • Not the ideal formula for oily hair


SHEA MOISTURE Jamaican Black Castor Oil Shampoo

The next shampoo is a simple recipe that uses Jamaican black castor oil as the main ingredient. That, combined with other high-quality ingredients, creates a formula that helps moisturize and leaves your hair clean.

Product Highlights

Here are the main features you can expect with this product:

  • Mineral oil-free
  • Sulfate & paraben free
  • Gluten-free
  • Color-safe
  • Cruelty-free
  • Sustainably sourced ingredients

The Good

If you have tried other natural organic shampoos before, then you probably have noticed they don’t lather well. One of the things we love about this product is that it actually does lather up a little. Then, when it does, it rinses out easily. To make this shampoo the best, the team at Shea Moisture uses prime ingredients.

Combined together, these ingredients have many attributes that help with moisturization and revitalization, which means you can use it as a conditioner, too. Along with that, the ingredients also gifted this shampoo with a very soothing scent.

The Bad

Whenever you are dealing with something that uses natural ingredients, you must be cautious of allergic reactions. There have been a few individuals who have suffered from irritated skin and rashes. Another issue is directly related to a specific hair type. If you have curly hair, this formula will not work well for you.

The good news is that, as long as you are careful and don’t deal with curly hair, this shampoo will leave your hair light and revitalized.


  • Does not leave hair dry and brittle
  • Lathers well and rinses out easily, leaving hair soft and smooth
  • Ingredients used in the formula make a conditioner unnecessary
  • Fragrance is very soothing and gentle


  • Some have had allergic reactions
  • Doesn’t work well with curly hair


Tru Moroccan Hydrating Repair Shampoo

Our last shampoo is crafted with argan oil, plus several plants and tree extracts that are carefully formulated to help treat dry and damaged hair. This hydrating repair shampoo is one of the best options on the market today.

Product Highlights

Here are the main features you can expect with this product:

  • Vegan-friendly
  • Whole foods and plant-based ingredients
  • Sulfate, phthalate, & paraben free
  • Cruelty-free
  • Color-safe

The Good

A lot of natural or organic shampoos are not great for daily use, as the ingredients often dry out scalps or strip necessary natural oils if used on a daily basis. This formula is different, though. It is gentle enough that it leaves no residue, nor does it remove moisture.

Along with that, those who are worried about vegan and natural ingredients don’t have to worry, as all the ingredients fall into these categories. These ingredients also have other benefits, such as helping repair damage to the scalp. Plus, the orange scent is nice.

The Bad

There are some drawbacks when you look at this product, though. The first is that it is a weaker formula, and if you suffer from skin conditions on the scalp, it might not be good enough. Also, like most natural and organic shampoos, this product does not lather very well.

Either way, these issues were not enough to detract from the positive attributes of this shampoo. Because of this, we included it on our list.


  • Can be used daily due to the gentleness of the formula
  • Crafted with only all-natural and vegan-friendly ingredients
  • Capable of helping repair scalp damage and weak roots
  • Has a subtle citrus scent without using harsh chemicals


  • Not a super-strong formula so not great for those with skin conditions
  • Does not lather very well


Buyer’s Guide

Now, you have some ideas about shampoos that might work for your natural and organic hair care needs, but how did we choose them?

To curate this list, we looked at several factors that, when combined, will give you a high-quality, effective shampoo. The good thing is that this list of factors can also be used as a buyer’s guide that you can use to whittle your options down even further.

With that being said, let’s look at the factors we considered when building this list.

Key Ingredients

Of all the factors we considered, this may be the most important, as it is the ingredients that decide if the product is natural and organic. When you read the label, you want to look for organic and natural ingredients, like green tea, apple cider vinegar, and argan oil to name a few.

Then, you should also consider what your hair needs are. In other words, if you suffer from dry scalp and hair, you will want to look for a shampoo with ingredients that moisturize and soothe your scalp.


Scent will have no effect on the performance of the shampoo, but you don’t want to be stuck in the shower with something that doesn’t smell nice. Also, that scent tends to linger in your hair, so when you are looking for your shampoo, make sure to sniff out if it has a pleasant scent or not.

Hair Type

After you have looked at the ingredients to ensure that the shampoo is truly natural and organic, you will then want to think about your hair type. There will be some formulas that can be used on all hair types, and others are designed specifically for a certain type.

Understanding your hair is crucial to choosing the right product for you. You will also want to consider any hair conditions you have, like thinning hair or dandruff. Then, choose a shampoo with ingredients that will be the best for your hair.

Allergic Reactions To Certain Ingredients

To prevent any serious issues from arising, knowing what you are allergic to will help. Look at the ingredients, and if there are any ingredients you are allergic to, steer away from that product.

If you are unsure, you can take a small sample and apply it to your skin. Wait for a bit to see if there is any redness or bumps that appear, and this should be an indication that you are not allergic to the product.

Price Vs. Value

The last thing you need to consider is the budget you have for this purchase. Understanding what you need and are willing to do without can help you narrow down your selection even more. Remember, sometimes, it is worth it to spend a little extra if the value can be found.

Frequently Asked Questions

Now that you have an idea what to look for when shopping for a good natural organic shampoo, you may still have a few questions that need to be answered. To help you with this, we scoured online and found some of the most commonly asked questions. Here are the answers to those.

What is in organic shampoo?

When you look at a shampoo label and it reads organic, all that means is that it does not contain chemicals used in the standard shampoos we are all used to. Typically, organic shampoos use natural oils, herbal extracts, and minerals that are used instead to leave your hair healthier. When it comes to natural shampoos, this simply means that they are sulfate-free.

Why should you use organic shampoo?

There are a lot of reasons why organic shampoos are a great addition to your personal care routine, starting with the fact that they are not crafted with harsh synthetic chemicals and other toxic ingredients. These can cause other health issues, though.

The use of all-natural ingredients can be curated to target select hair issues and can even help balance the pH of your scalp. All of which is to say that it will leave your hair and scalp healthier.

From a responsibility aspect, organic shampoos are more biodegradable and better for the earth. On top of that, most of them are not tested on animals, and many of the companies give back to charitable causes.

How can I tell if my shampoo is natural?

The first thing you can do is look at the labels. You will want to look for ingredients that you have trouble pronouncing or any that don’t seem to be derived from natural ingredients. This will also give you a chance to look and see if there are any allergens you need to worry about, too.

You can also check the website of the company, as well as several other watchdog sites that keep track of EWG verifications. Chief amongst the things to look for to make sure that your shampoo is natural is if they contain sulfates or phthalates.

Why do organic & natural shampoos not lather much?

Most of us are used to standing under the shower and lathering our shampoo up to a frothy hat that sits on top of our head. Because of this, when we switch to natural and organic shampoos and don’t get the lather we are used to, we tend to freak out a little.

The truth is that natural and organic shampoos are not going to lather like traditional shampoos. This is because these shampoos have opted to eliminate sulfates from their formulas, which are the ingredients in standard shampoos that cause the lathering. Don’t worry, though, the shampoo is still getting the job done without that sudsy fun.

Can I make natural, organic shampoo?

When people see that the product they are looking at has ingredients they can easily get, many think about going DIY. With shampoo, it is very easy to do, and there are different formulas that you can find online. For instance, here is a recipe for a shampoo that will help with moisturization as well as balance the pH of your scalp:

  • 1 can full-fat coconut milk
  • 2 tbsps. raw honey (liquid)
  • 1 tsp. jojoba oil
  • 1 tsp. castor oil
  • 2 tbsps. apple cider vinegar
  • 1 tsp. the essential oil of your choice (we suggest lavender or tea tree)

Combine all the ingredients into a bottle and use as needed. DIY shampoos are easy enough to do, but you have to consider that you are not in the know when it comes to the quality of the ingredients you are pulling together. This is why, although it is possible to create your own shampoo, we suggest that you invest in a premade formula.

Final Thoughts

Choosing to switch out your standard shampoos for a natural organic option is a good thing not only for your hair’s health but also for the planet. In fact, there are so many benefits that you will be able to take advantage of. You may ask yourself why you didn’t switch sooner.

Before you can celebrate, you have to make the choice, and that can be difficult. There are a lot of great shampoos out there, and we have looked at a few that we consider the best natural organic shampoos on the market. To choose them, we carefully researched each and used our list of factors to weed out the ones that just didn’t cut it.
Hopefully, by doing this, we have helped make your decision easier and less tiresome.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *